GTA 6 2 min read

GTA 6 shows a major critic-player split as user scores shift

GTA 6 has opened with a major critic-player rating gap. Early Metacritic figures show a volatile user response, but the available data does not prove every low score is coordinated.

A black gaming controller rests on a wooden desk in front of a colorful backdrop with rising light effects, a nighttime city skyline, and computer monitors.
AI-generated illustration

Grand Theft Auto 6 is facing a sharp split between critic and player ratings one day after its November 19 launch. Insider Gaming reported that the game had a 5.1 out of 10 user score on Metacritic from more than 10,000 ratings, with nearly half marked negative. That pattern has led to review-bombing accusations, although the available evidence shows a rapidly changing player snapshot rather than a definitive explanation for every low score.

What the ratings show

Metacritic’s critic and user figures describe very different reactions. The site lists GTA 6 at 99 out of 100 from 152 critic reviews, with all 152 classified as positive. Insider Gaming’s November 20 snapshot placed the user score at 5.1 out of 10, or 51 out of 100. On that like-for-like scale, the gap between the critic average and the reported player average was 48 percentage points.

That calculation uses Metacritic’s 99-point critic score and Insider Gaming’s reported 5.1 user score. It is a useful measure of the disagreement, but not a final verdict: both user totals and the average can move quickly during the first hours after a major release, and a user score does not establish why an individual player submitted a rating.

The timing also matters. Vaagame recorded Metacritic’s user reviews opening at noon Pacific on November 20 and captured an initial 3.7 out of 10 from 157 ratings. A later Metacritic search snapshot showed 5.0 from 3,993 user ratings, split between 40 percent positive, 10 percent mixed and 50 percent negative. Those different readings demonstrate how quickly the displayed score changed as more ratings arrived.

The figures therefore support a substantial early backlash, but they do not by themselves prove coordinated review bombing. Insider Gaming found a mixture of complaints in the submitted comments, including performance problems, lost progress, comparisons with Red Dead Redemption 2, political criticism and racist remarks. The outlet also described some one-line zero scores and ratings tied to expectations such as a perfect 100, which are examples of submissions that can distort a launch-period average.

The baseline for players

The contrast is especially pronounced against the pre-launch review baseline. Rockstar’s launch announcement described GTA 6 as the highest-rated game in history, while Metacritic’s listing documented the 99 critic score on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S. The game officially launched on those two console families on November 19, according to Rockstar Support.

For players deciding whether the reaction applies to them, the platform and sample remain important. GTA 6 launched on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S, and the reported user figures aggregate ratings rather than separating every technical experience by console. The most defensible conclusion at this stage is that player opinion is far less uniform than the critic consensus; calling the entire result a review bomb goes beyond what the rating totals alone can establish.

Discuss in the forum

What do you think about this story? Start the discussion in our forum.

Discuss in the forum →